In 1908, a Scottish physiologist and two collaborators published a paper that changed how divers returned from depth. Their work combined animal experiments, a mathematical model of nitrogen uptake, and a practical alternative to slow, uniform ascent.
The story is often shortened to “Haldane and the goats.” The real contribution was more careful: John Scott Haldane, pathologist A. E. Boycott, and Royal Navy officer G. C. C. Damant developed a way to think about decompression in stages, based on how nitrogen behaves differently across the body. That framework became an important ancestor of later Navy tables and modern compartment models.
The problem: compressed-air illness
By the early 1900s, divers and workers in pressurized caissons were suffering from what was then called “compressed-air illness,” or caisson disease. Cases could be crippling or fatal. The causes were not yet well understood, and existing approaches favored slow, relatively uniform decompression.
The British Admiralty wanted practical rules for Royal Navy divers. It commissioned Haldane to investigate decompression in 1905. The work that followed was not a single-person effort: Boycott, Damant, and Haldane carried out the experimental program and published its findings together.

Why goats, and what the experiments suggested
The team used goats as a large-animal model for decompression experiments. They were practical subjects for observing the effects of pressure changes, and their respiratory exchange made them useful for the research. The goal was to learn how nitrogen entered and left the body, and what happened when pressure was reduced.
One finding mattered for the model: different parts of the body absorbed and released nitrogen at different rates. Some regions changed relatively quickly; others took much longer. The researchers represented these differences with five theoretical tissue compartments, each assigned a nitrogen half-time: 5, 10, 20, 40, and 75 minutes.
A half-time is the time required for a modeled compartment to move halfway toward a new gas pressure. The compartments were mathematical abstractions, not five specific organs. Together, they gave the researchers a way to represent fast and slow nitrogen exchange within the body.
The critical ratio: a limit for supersaturation
Haldane’s group proposed that decompression became unsafe if nitrogen pressure within the body rose much more than roughly twice the surrounding nitrogen pressure. This is commonly summarized as a critical supersaturation ratio of about 2:1.
The distinction matters. The ratio concerns nitrogen pressure, not a simple comparison between total tissue pressure and total ambient pressure. It was a working model based on the experiments and assumptions of the time, not a universal guarantee against decompression sickness.
That idea challenged the standard approach. If tissues could tolerate a limited pressure difference, a diver might rise more quickly at first, then pause in stages while nitrogen continued to leave the body.
Staged decompression replaces a uniform ascent
Instead of ascending slowly at a uniform rate, the proposed method was to ascend relatively quickly to a first stop (approximately where absolute pressure had been reduced by half) then continue upward in controlled stages.
The logic was counterintuitive for its time. A uniform ascent seemed cautious, but the research suggested it could spend too long at higher pressure and then move too quickly near the surface. Staged decompression aimed to use the changing pressure difference to help tissues desaturate progressively.

The broad concept remains familiar to divers: ascent may include stops at specific depths rather than one uninterrupted, uniform climb. But the historical method is not a current dive-planning procedure. Its assumptions, tables, and limits belong to their era.
The 1908 paper and Royal Navy adoption
The findings appeared in The Journal of Hygiene in the paper “The Prevention of Compressed-air Illness,” authored by Boycott, Damant, and Haldane. The paper’s publication in 1908 is a useful historical marker. A confidential report to the Admiralty had appeared earlier, in 1907, but the journal publication made the work publicly available.
The Royal Navy adopted Haldane’s tables in 1908, and they were used for decades. The five-compartment model and staged ascent provided a foundation for later decompression tables and further research.
For a closer look at present-day U.S. Navy procedures, see our guides to Navy dive tables and U.S. Navy Rev 7 and Table 9-8, residual nitrogen time, and repetitive dives. If you use the printable Table 9-7 card, treat it as a study aid and consult the complete manual for the applicable procedure.
From five compartments to modern planning
The lineage is not a straight line in which each later table simply copied Haldane’s numbers. Decompression research developed and revised the models, assumptions, and operational procedures. U.S. Navy tables, including the modern Rev 7 Change A procedures covered in our series, are later refinements, not Haldane’s original tables in new packaging.
The enduring connection is the compartment approach: model nitrogen loading in multiple theoretical tissue groups with different uptake and elimination rates, then apply rules to manage ascent. Modern Bühlmann ZHL-16C planning uses 16 compartments rather than Haldane’s five and includes later refinements such as M-values and gradient factors. These models are not identical, and their outputs should not be mixed as if they were interchangeable.

Today, DiveCommand uses Bühlmann ZHL-16C. Its published validation reports 4.83 million checks, including 919,360 no-decompression limits checked against an independent reference model. The company also reports zero difference across 12,067 test cases compared with Shearwater, Garmin, and Suunto computers under the tested settings. Computer settings and conventions can still differ, so matching results should be interpreted in that context. For commercial operations, NavCommand runs U.S. Navy Rev 7 tables digitally.
What Haldane got right, and what changed
Haldane’s work established several ideas that still shape decompression theory:
- Nitrogen uptake and release vary across modeled tissue groups.
- A diver’s ascent can be planned in stages.
- Decompression procedures need to account for both exposure and tissue loading, not just a uniform ascent rate.
But a historical model is not a modern safety standard. The 2:1 ratio and original tables do not account for every factor relevant to an individual or every present-day dive profile. Later models and procedures were developed as researchers refined the evidence and the mathematics.
Do not plan a modern dive with Haldane’s historical tables. This article is educational. Use the current procedure appropriate to your training, equipment, dive, and operating standards. Software can help apply a defined planning method; it does not replace training, qualified supervision, or established safety procedures.
Sources and further reading
- Boycott, A. E., Damant, G. C. C., and Haldane, J. S., “The Prevention of Compressed-air Illness,” Journal of Hygiene, 1908.
- CMAS fact sheet: Haldane 1908.
- DIVER Magazine: “Dive Tables and Decompression Models”.
- Haldane’s decompression model.